Monday, February 18, 2013

Girls - "Boys" - Review

Identity has always played a major role in Girls. It’s apparent more broadly in the characters figuring out who they are and what they want to be. But it also exists in the characters putting on personas to escape their true selves.

Hannah has tried on a number of identities in her escapades to become the “voice of her generation”. A task she’s discovered, as she pointed out last episode, to be exhausting. 

Shoshanna is as refreshing as she often is because of how sincere she is. She rarely if ever is hiding her true identity; it’s there for all to see (the case is similar with Adam). Her alarming honest unnerves Ray who is at a crossroads in his life. Ray, at 33, is older than the rest of the main characters. He knows who he is, but he’s not exactly where he wants to be or hoped he’d be at when he was Hannah and Shoshanna’s age. He feigns to have his shit together, but deep down he feels like a complete “loser”.

Hannah believes her career is taking off just as she’d anticipated, but she’s lying to herself. The e-book is a nice starting point, but as the random partygoer notes, “It’s not a book. It’s just an e-book”. This isn’t what Hannah wants to be writing about. Even the “12 Fruits that Make You Fat” article on her laptop is more appealing to her than writing this drivel. 

Marnie deep down knows her relationship with Booth Jonathan isn’t anything special or meaningful. But Marnie is so desperate for attention that she willfully ignores the telltale signs that douchey artist Booth could care less about her (as if the slightly disturbingly misogynistic undertones of how he treated her weren’t enough). So when she lets it slip out that she thinks they’re boyfriend and girlfriend, she’s given a rude (but not all that unexpected) awakening. 

Just like Ray and Hannah, she’s lying to herself. None of them want to be where they’re at. This lack of enamoration is true both of their mindset towards their life goals as well as the particular, specific situations they’re in. Ray just wanted to get his copy of Little Women and be done with Adam, but instead he’s forced to traverse to Staten Island to return a stolen dog. In the process he’s reminded of how unhappy he is with his life. 

If the point weren’t clear enough, the next to last scene finds Marnie and Hannah calling eachother. They both want to speak what’s on their minds; they want to fix their friendship, but neither can admit it. Rather than do the one thing they want, they continue to accept the touted identities they’ve adopted and lie to themselves and eachother. 

Marnie and Hannah may be barely concealing tears (as well as their real selves) by episode’s end, but Ray, finally by himself, is free to shed the identity that has become his cross to bear. The final shot is of him crying, completely honest about who he is. 

Stray Observations:

-Adam was too good of a character for the series not to find some way to bring him back, and Ray and Adam make a surprisingly funny and well-matched pairing.
-Adam named the dog “Dog”.
-“This is what it must have been like to storm to the beaches of Normandy” – The whole conversation between Adam and Ray on the ferry is great.
-Jessa doesn’t get much screentime but I love “depressed” Jessa noting “This book’s not going to matter”
-Adam’s “carnival game” analogy of Hannah felt pretty accurate to me.
-“She was accepting of my brand of difficult”
-The woman we meet who is the daughter of the dogowner was a smidge bizarre. I don’t know if the language here was pushing the limits.
-“You’re a hostess for a living”
-“I think I liked the idea of you”
-The episode didn’t feel like it warranted the title “Boys”. Sure, there a fair amount of time spent with Adam and Ray, but it didn’t feel like it deserved that title. 

Grade: B+

What did everyone else think?

No comments:

Post a Comment